TradeDots vs Trade Ideas — two AI takes on active trading.
Trade Ideas pioneered AI scanning for retail. TradeDots took a different path: a focused AI Score that ranks 1,000 stocks, plus a TradingView-native indicator suite. Different shapes, overlapping audience.
Trade Ideas is the right pick if you want a standalone scanner platform with a mature library of AI-driven strategies (Holly), and you don't mind a Windows-first desktop client. TradeDots is the right pick if your day starts in TradingView and you want a focused Heat List rank + a curated indicator suite that drops into the charts you already use. The audience overlaps but the workflows are genuinely different — try TradeDots's free tier first if you're undecided.
TradeDots vs Trade Ideas — side by side.
Where TradeDots wins
Workflow fit if you already use TradingView. The indicators install into the charts you're already analyzing on. No new platform to learn, no new window to flip between — the analysis lives inside the chart layout.
Cross-platform reach. TradeDots is web-first, so it works the same on Mac, Windows, iOS, and Android. Trade Ideas's full client is a Windows desktop application — perfectly fine if you trade from a Windows workstation, less convenient if you don't.
A free entry point. The 20+ free TradeDots indicators on TradingView let you evaluate the indicator quality before paying for anything. Trade Ideas doesn't have a free tier — you start at the paid tier.
Where Trade Ideas wins
Strategy variety. Holly AI runs multiple strategies in parallel — different time horizons, different setups. TradeDots ships one ranking signal (the AI Score) and lets the trader form the strategy on top of that. If you want a library of AI strategies to evaluate, Trade Ideas has the breadth.
Backtesting. Trade Ideas's built-in strategy backtester is mature. TradeDots backtesting is on the roadmap but not yet shipped.
Scanner depth. Trade Ideas was built scanner-first; the scanner is the product. TradeDots solves scanning indirectly through the Heat List ranking, which is a different mental model.
Common questions about TradeDots vs Trade Ideas.
See for yourself.
Free TradingView indicators. No card required. Try the Heat List in the app.